First off- @J - great idea about the “Recent Comments”. I actually already set it up last week, but never activated it because it seemed to clutter my sidebar. But I finally fixed my sidebar code to keep all the fonts and bullets the same size (and now &. looking), so I thought it would be nice to through them in there. Looks good (Also, please notice the retooled comment bar between posts, which highlights the comments a little more too, encouraging you to add something), I think and it makes it seem like there’s a good community here.
Which brings me to my actual topic today: Building communication through blogs. Because as much as I like the idea of people just reading my ideas on things, I’m enjoying this blog because people are writing back. Jeff Jarvis from BuzzMachine (great blog!) recently had an amazing anecdote which explains his theory behind blogs
“When I was in London, I sat with folks from the BBC in an afternoon devoted to blogging, and the woman next to me was troubled, bearing weight on her shoulders from having to fill her blog and manage her blog. To her, the blog was a thing, a beast that needed to be fed, a never-ending sheet of blank paper. I turned to her and said she should see past the blog. It’s not a show with a rundown that, without feeding, turns into dead air. Indeed, if you look at it that way, you’ll probably write crappy blog posts. I’ve said before that if I think I need to write a post just because I haven’t written one, I inevitably come out with something forced and bad. Instead, I blog when I find something interesting that I’ve seen and I think, ‘I have to tell my friends about that.’ You’re the friends. So yes, I said, it’s just a conversation. And reading — hearing what others are saying — is every bit as important as writing. It was as if scales were lifted from her eyes and weight from her back: She’s just talking with people.”
I thought that was just awesome advice. I’ve always spoken out against “posting for the sake of posting”. If you are thinking about posting on your blog simply because you haven’t recently, then something has gone wrong. Furthermore, if you are sitting at your computer trying to think of something to write about then you’ve really gone down the wrong path. The way I see this blog is that throughout my day I’m learning some really cool things about social media, technology, gadgets (although that’s more on my own time…), and other general nerdery. I think these things are fun and I want to pass along what I’ve learned.
But the catch 22 in the BuzzMachine quote is that to really have an online conversation through your blog, you need a community. But the best way to build a community is through writing great posts on your blog… (this is, by the way, the problem I help solve for a living). The difficulty in starting a blog is there there is no real community behind it yet. Without a real community there will be no comments and a blog without comments is basically a newsletter.
So I definitely need to take this time to thank my valiant readers, but even more so- thanks to my commenters. You’ve brought up some good points and it’s made me want to keep writing. Like J said in a comment earlier “Wow. You are seriously pushing the boundaries of being a Web 1.99 site. If you start implementing user-suggested ideas . . . you may have to bump your version number.”
Well it’s time to start pushing the boundaries more. Which reminds me - Drew, expect an entire post dedicated to your Jason Kelly link and a post about the WinMo add-ons you finally set up- that’ll be fun too.
I’ll make this a little more web 1.999ish and address J’s other comments from today: I’ve already addressed the new “recent comments” section, but as for timestamps on posts- won’t happen. I worked way too hard to take them out of my template to put them back in. My original thought was that I don’t want people knowing that I post late at night, like a nerd or something, but I also just don’t like the way it looks (AND- you’re spot on: it takes away the pressure of posting more often…)
So keep those comments coming and if you’re just lurking- well that’s ok, but at least give me a shout out hello or something. To encourage more comments I’m going to try to remember to end each post with a question from now on- this way, if no one responds, then I’ll just have to ask more interesting questions, or write more interesting posts… starting off, I’ll try to keep the questions related to the day’s post.
Today’s question:
Are you now or have you ever been an active commenter (more than once or twice) on any other blogs? If so, which ones? If not, why? And why yes for this one? What about online forums?
PS- From now on I’ll also try to make the questions less Job-Interview sounding.



December 20th, 2007 at 7:48 am
Couple things:
1) Great job responding to input, whether you decide to implement or not. Also, the comment portion at the bottom of each post is very well-done now. I was actually going to comment on that yesterday but didn’t want to overwhelm you. The font and background made it hard to see when the link had already been visited.
2) You must know that by quoting me, you have now cemented me as a R4L (reader for life). Hot diggity dog.
3) I kept a blog for six months. It got to the point where posting felt forced, so I ended it. You’re very correct about the necessity of free idea flow and community.
4a) Blogs I actively comment- wcuk, AngryMark and TheNinjaDon (all cyclists). Some of them have gotten away from cycling-related posts but I still comment occasionally nonetheless.
4b) Blogs I read nearly every day but do not comment- Information Arbitrage, Seeking Alpha, DealBreaker - all finance-related blogs. (Seeking Alpha is a blog aggregator of sorts)
4c) Slashdot, too, of course. Don’t comment as much anymore.
4d) I don’t comment on the finance blogs because I feel that there are many others with far more qualified views than my own so I leave the commenting to others. I do comment on this blog because I feel comfortable commending or criticizing the post author as well as the comment authors without worrying that they will take something personally. I also genuinely enjoy the prospect of orderly argument and disagreement that runs no risk of devolving into flaming.
p.s. thanks again for the preview button, it let me check all the links. Keep up the fantastic work.
December 20th, 2007 at 8:29 am
@J
Excellent feedback! Now that I have an R4L, I guess I’ll have to become a W4L - I like the motivation.
It seems though, as I’m continually working out the kinks to the blog, your comment was trapped in moderation limbo… That’s frustrating, seeing as how you’re an R4L and all.
I’ll work on setting something new up so that never happens again.
December 21st, 2007 at 11:51 am
Great post Z. I thought the comments on posting were great and spot on. Forcing anything just isn’t that fun is it? And it usually comes out crappy, no matter what it is.
As far as the blog question - I don’t post a lot. This blog certainly contains most of my posts. I like the regular tech blogs (gizmodo, engadget, boy genius) and I like video game blogs as well (joystiq, kotaku, 360fanboy). But again, I rarely post. To be honest, I don’t see the point a lot of the time - I like the discussion aspect of this blog, but a lot of the blogs I visit aren’t really like that. I don’t really care about some guy, I don’t know, opinion. I do like the Q&A blogs you find on a lot of mobile sites. People helping out others is really great I think. And you can almost always find an answer.
If I don’t comment before the Holiday, everyone enjoy it.
-Drew